Photographer Who Took Kate Middleton and Prince William Car Photo Addresses New Editing Speculation

After Princess Kate’s Mother’s Day photo came under fire for editing errors, another image of the royal was accused of manipulation

Another image of Kate Middleton is under scrutiny.

The Princess of Wales, 42, issued an apology on Monday surrounding the Mother’s Day image that was pulled by multiple news agencies due to suspicions of manipulation. Hours later, she was photographed in the backseat of a car with Prince William leaving Windsor Castle. While Prince William, 41, headed to the Commonwealth Day service at Westminster Abbey in London that day, PEOPLE understands that Princess Kate was heading to a private appointment.

Speculation arose online that the latest picture was also doctored, with social media users citing a difference in how the brick wall behind the vehicle looked through the window versus above the car.

The photo agency that captured the pictures, Goff Photos, denied editing the images. While they told E! News that the pics “have been cropped and lightened,” they clarified that “nothing has been doctored.”

Jim Bennett, the photographer who snapped the photos, tells PEOPLE, “We don’t change our photos in Photoshop other than adjusting the light levels if necessary. Car shots are unpredictable at the best of times and with some reflection on the glass it can be difficult.”

Bennett expected to see Prince William heading to London for the Commonwealth Day service.
He says, “It wasn’t until I checked on the back of the camera to make sure I had a frame of Prince William that I realized there was someone sitting next to him. It turned out to be Catherine!”

The Princess of Wales has been out of the public eye since Christmas as she recovers from an abdominal surgery that took place on Jan. 16. The Mother’s Day photo shared over the weekend marked the first official portrait of the royal since her procedure. Although the palace released the image likely with hopes of quelling rumors about Princess Kate’s health that have been circulating online, the snap quickly came under fire for multiple editing errors. Later on the day it was released, major photo agencies issued a “kill notification” on the image.

“We became aware of concerns about the image and we carried a report about it last night, and made clear that we were seeking urgent clarification about the image from Kensington Palace,” PA Media, one of the agencies that removed the photo from their service, said. “In the absence of that clarification, we are killing the image from our picture service.”

Princess Kate said in a statement on Monday, “Like many amateur photographers, I do occasionally experiment with editing. I wanted to express my apologies for any confusion the family photograph we shared yesterday caused. I hope everyone celebrating had a very happy Mother’s Day.” The message was signed with a “C” for Catherine, indicating that the note came directly from Kate.